Contents Winter 2018 Vol. 60, No. 1 3 Creative Continuity Daniel McCarthy Countering the Counterrevolution Narrative Jesse Merriam 22 The Libertarian Constitutional Fantasy Mark Pulliam 42 René Girard's Challenge to Fusionism Donald J. Devine 61 Natural Law and Human Motives Pierre Manent 86 Charlemagne's European Project- and Rémi Brague's Paul Seaton Autonomy on the Road to Tyranny Richard M. Reinsch II 118 Whom God Would Ruin Trans: Gender and Race in an Age of Unsettled Identities By Rogers Brubaker R. V. Young 126 Against Identity Politics The Once and Future Liberal: After Identity Politics By Mark Lilla Aurelian Craiutu Essays 6 104 Reviews modernagejournal.com 1http://www.modernagejournal.com