Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 123

Reviews

The much-tweeted claim that transracial is "not a thing" was a
superficial slogan, driven more by political positioning than by
intellectual analysis. Yet it pointed to an undeniable truth. Transracial is indeed not a thing in the same sense as transgender; it is
not a socially recognized and validated identity. Transgender, by
contrast, has been socially defined as real; it is therefore-in the
words of the now-classic Thomas theorem-"real" in [its] consequences." Transgender has been recognized, validated, and institutionalized in cultural idioms, public narratives, ways of thinking
and feeling, social practices, legal and organizational categories,
political claims-making, social science research, and popular culture. For a nontrivial segment of the population, transgender is no
longer a contested novelty; it is a taken-for-granted reality. Nothing comparable can be said about transracial.

Would it serve any purpose to remind Brubaker that in the notso-distant past the intrinsic inferiority of African Americans was
"a taken-for-granted reality" by a "nontrivial segment of the
population"?
Further, there is the danger of thinking in the wrong way and
associating intellectually with the wrong kind of people that
would be devastating for anyone's progressive credentials: Hypatia: A Journal of Feminist Philosophy was recently excoriated for
publishing "In Defense of Transracialism" by Rebecca Tuvel, an
assistant professor of philosophy at Rhodes College. According
to a report in The Chronicle of Higher Education, "Critics blasted
the article as a product of white and cisgender privilege, said it
discounted important scholarly work by transgender and black
academics, and accused its author of using harmful language."
Evidently worried about such a response, Brubaker attempts
to distinguish his own argument from anything that smacks of
modernagejournal.com

123



http://www.modernagejournal.com

Modern Age - Winter 2018

Table of Contents for the Digital Edition of Modern Age - Winter 2018

Contents
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - Cover1
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - Cover2
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - Contents
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 2
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 3
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 4
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 5
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 6
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 7
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 8
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 9
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 10
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 11
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 12
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 13
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 14
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 15
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 16
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 17
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 18
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 19
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 20
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 21
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 22
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 23
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 24
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 25
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 26
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 27
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 28
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 29
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 30
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 31
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 32
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 33
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 34
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 35
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 36
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 37
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 38
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 39
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 40
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 41
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 42
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 43
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 44
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 45
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 46
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 47
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 48
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 49
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 50
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 51
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 52
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 53
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 54
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 55
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 56
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 57
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 58
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 59
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 60
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 61
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 62
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 63
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 64
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 65
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 66
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 67
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 68
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 69
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 70
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 71
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 72
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 73
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 74
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 75
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 76
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 77
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 78
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 79
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 80
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 81
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 82
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 83
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 84
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 85
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 86
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 87
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 88
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 89
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 90
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 91
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 92
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 93
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 94
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 95
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 96
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 97
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 98
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 99
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 100
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 101
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 102
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 103
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 104
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 105
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 106
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 107
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 108
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 109
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 110
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 111
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 112
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 113
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 114
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 115
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 116
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 117
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 118
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 119
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 120
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 121
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 122
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 123
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 124
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 125
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 126
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 127
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 128
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 129
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 130
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 131
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 132
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 133
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 134
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 135
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 136
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 137
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 138
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 139
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 140
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 141
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 142
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 143
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 144
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 145
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 146
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 147
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 148
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 149
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 150
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 151
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 152
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 153
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 154
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 155
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 156
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 157
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 158
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 159
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 160
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 161
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 162
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 163
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 164
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 165
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - 166
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - Cover3
Modern Age - Winter 2018 - Cover4
https://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/isi/modernage_2018winter
https://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/isi/modernage_2017fall
https://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/isi/modernage_2017summer
https://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/isi/modernage_2017spring
https://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/isi/modernage_2017winter
https://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/isi/modernage_2016fall
https://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/isi/modernage_2016summer
https://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/isi/modernage_2016spring
https://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/isi/modernage_2016winter
https://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/isi/modernage_2015fall
https://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/isi/modernage_2014fall
https://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/isi/modernage_2014summer
https://www.nxtbookmedia.com